Idaho Supreme Court: Misdemeanor arrests not lawful unless officer saw the crime or has a warrant

In this June 8, 2017 file photo the Idaho Supreme Court building is seen in Boise, Idaho. The Idaho Supreme Court says law enforcement officers can't arrest someone for a misdemeanor unless they have a warrant or actually saw the crime being committed. The unanimous ruling made Wednesday, June 12, 2109, has advocacy organizations and law enforcement groups scrambling, because it likely means police will have to dramatically change how they respond to domestic violence calls.(AP Photo/Rebecca Boone,File)

By REBECCA BOONE,  Associated Press  BOISE, Idaho (AP) 06/12 — The Idaho Supreme Court says law enforcement officers can’t arrest someone for a misdemeanor unless they have a warrant or actually saw the crime being committed.

The unanimous ruling made Wednesday has advocacy organizations scrambling because it likely means police will have to dramatically change how they respond to some domestic violence calls.

The ruling came in a drug conviction case in which the drugs were found after a man was arrested — without a warrant — on a misdemeanor battery charge for allegedly groping someone outside the sight of an officer.

The high court noted the Idaho Constitution’s provision against unlawful search and seizure doesn’t allow warrantless arrests without probable cause. That means no misdemeanor arrests unless the officer saw the crime — and without an arrest, the man’s drugs wouldn’t have been found. As a result, the court ordered that the man’s drug conviction be overturned.

The implications of the case are broad. Patrick Orr, spokesman for the Ada County Sheriff’s Office, said his agency is still working out what the ruling means and what changes the department will need to make in the future. Officers responding to domestic violence calls often arrest the person they suspect of committing the violence on a misdemeanor charge as a way of separating those involved and diffusing the situation.

Annie Pelletier Hightower, the director of law and policy with the Idaho Coalition Against Sexual and Domestic Violence, says the ruling makes it harder for law enforcement to create safety in many calls involving sexual battery, child abuse, stalking or other crimes that typically happen in a private location. The coalition works with several organizations and law enforcement agencies in an effort to address the root causes of violence in communities and improve the response to abuse.

“From about noon I started receiving kind of panicked calls and emails and that has continued for the last several hours,” Hightower said Wednesday afternoon. “People aren’t quite sure what to make of it, and there’s a lot of fear and a lot of thought going into, ‘What does this actually mean for our communities right now?'”

The ruling, written by Justice Joel Horton, noted that it wasn’t until 1979 that Idaho lawmakers added a state law that allowed the warrantless arrest of someone if the officer reasonably believed that the person had committed a misdemeanor assault or battery outside the presence of the officer. But Horton said that law didn’t meet the constitutional standard barring unlawful searches and seizures. He said that’s especially important because when the Constitution was written, the common law of the land was that people couldn’t be arrested for minor crimes without a warrant.

The same was true in many other states, Horton said, and prohibitions against misdemeanor warrantless arrests were even upheld in the U.S. Supreme Court in the early 1900s.

Horton said that history makes it clear the framers of Idaho’s constitution understood that their wording prohibited warrantless arrests for completed misdemeanors.

“We are fully mindful of the significance of this conclusion,” Horton wrote. “Idaho Code … permits peace officers to use their arrest powers to intervene in domestic violence situations, even though they have not personally observed the commission of a crime, and to thereby defuse potentially violent circumstances.”

Still, he wrote, the “extremely powerful policy considerations” that support allowing warrantless misdemeanor arrests “must yield to the requirements of the Idaho Constitution.”

Hightower said the ruling will tax already overstretched community organizations working to protect victims of domestic violence.

“We know there is this body of research that showing that the separation of individuals in the relationship reduces risk. If law enforcement doesn’t have the opportunity to separate by arrest, then we’re back into the situation where it is the person who has experienced abuse and who is in the most upheaval, likely with the fewest resources, forced to leave the home,” she said. “As a community, how do we support those survivors leaving their homes?”

Hightower said she’s checking with other states to see if any similar rulings have been made elsewhere, and how those states have dealt with any changes.

“Everyone is starting to explore policy options. I don’t know if a constitutional amendment will be viable in this state or not, but there are also other solutions we can explore,” she said.

For instance, some states have 24-hour online court access where domestic violence victims can seek protection orders at any time of day, not just when the courthouse is open.

“Realistically that would be a very big burden on the judiciary, which is already stressed,” she said. “None of these are easy options.”

https://www.apnews.com/6730a7e1cf0542829723f2b1db39194d

Copyright 2019 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Posted in: Arrests, Assault, Court Rulings, Domestic Violence, Drugs/Drug Trafficking, Exonerations, Police, Policies & Practices

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

nineteen − 11 =

Terms of Use for Posting Comments

Terms of Use

This site (the “Site”) is operated and maintained by Law Enforcement Education Foundation, Corporation (“Company”). Throughout the Site, the terms “we”, “us” and “our” refer to Company.  The words “user,” “you” and “your” as used herein refer to you.

Please read these terms and conditions of use (“Terms of Use”) carefully before contributing content. If you do not agree to these Terms of Use, please do not contribute content. Your use of the Site is subject to the Terms and Conditions found here .

By contributing content to the Site, you represent and warrant that you are at least eighteen (18) years old and that you have read and understand these Terms of Use and any amendments thereto and agree to be bound by them. If you are not at least eighteen (18) years old or you do not agree and accept these Terms of Use, you are prohibited from contributing content.

From time to time, we may permit users to submit content to the Site.  You hereby acknowledge and agree that by submitting remarks, comments, suggestions, ideas, graphics, feedback, edits, concepts, comments, photographs, illustrations and other materials (other than personal information and/or registration information) through the Site (individually and collectively, “Submissions”), you (i) grant us a nonexclusive, royalty-free, perpetual, transferable, irrevocable and fully sub-licensable right to use, reproduce, modify, adapt, translate, distribute, publish, create derivative works from and publicly display and perform such Submissions throughout the world in any media, now known or hereafter created, without attribution to you; (ii) grant us the right to pursue at law any person or entity that violates your and/or our rights in your Submissions; and (iii) forever waive any and all of your rights, including but not limited to moral rights, if any, in and to your Submissions, including, without limitation, any all rights or requirements of attribution or identification of you as the author of the Submission or any derivative thereof.  We reserve the right to remove any of your Submissions from the Site, in whole or in part, without notice to you, for any reason or no reason.

Submissions are made voluntarily. Any submissions which include personally identifiable information are subject to our Privacy Policy found here .  You may not upload or otherwise publish content on the Site that (i) is confidential to you or any third party; (ii) is untrue, inaccurate, false or other than an original work of your authorship; (iii) that relates to or impersonates any other person; (iv) violates the copyright, trademark, patent or other intellectual property rights of any person or entity; (v) contains any content, personally identifiable information or other information, or materials of any kind that relate or refer to any other person or entity other than the provider of the products, goods or services to which the Submission relates; or (vi) violates any law, or in any manner infringes or interferes with the rights of others, including but not limited to the use of names, information, or materials that (A) libel, defame, or invade the privacy of any third party, (B) are obscene or pornographic, (C) are harmful, threatening, offensive, abusive, harassing, vulgar, false or inaccurate, racially, sexually, ethnically or are otherwise objectionable or otherwise contrary to the laws of any place where such Submissions may be accessed; (D) constitute personal attacks on other individuals; (E) promote criminal, immoral or illegal activity; (F) promote or advertise any person, product or service or solicit funds; or (G) are deemed confidential by any contract or policy.

You are solely responsible for any Submissions you make and their accuracy. We take no responsibility and assume no liability for any Submissions posted by you or any third party.

Unless approved by us in writing in advance, you agree not to: (i) provide or create a link to the Site; or (ii) create any frames at any other sites pertaining to any of the content located on the Site.

We reserve the right, in our discretion, to update, change or replace any part of these Terms of Use for Posting Comments by posting updates and/or changes to our Site.  It is your responsibility to check this page periodically for changes.  Your continued use of, and/or access to the Site, following the posting of any changes to these Terms of Use for Posting Comments, constitutes your acceptance of those changes.